Home Winemaker Profiles Serbia ERNŐ SAGMEISTER: Take the Same Road, and Your Thinking Dies

ERNŐ SAGMEISTER: Take the Same Road, and Your Thinking Dies

2465

It is around a hundred and fifty kilometres from Kanjiža to Ernő Sagmeister’s vineyards on Fruška Gora. He makes the journey almost every day, but not always by the same road. Sometimes he drives through Senta, sometimes through Horgoš, and sometimes he chooses villages nobody would pass through if they wanted to reach their destination as quickly as possible.

“If you keep taking the same road, your thinking dies.”

The destination is always the same: three vineyards around Irig, differing in soil, slope, wind and the wines they produce. When he arrives, he walks among the vines, looks at what has changed since the previous day and returns to Kanjiža. The next morning, he sets off for Fruška Gora again, though not necessarily by the same route.

It is difficult to find a straight line in his biography. He studied civil engineering, taught mathematics, bought wild elderberries, distilled rakija and made wine for himself. He entered professional winemaking only when a friend offered something that sounded like a poorly devised trap: the friend would put up all the money, give Ernő half the business and transfer half the land into his name.

Before all that, he was a boy accompanying his grandfather Ernest to a vineyard near Subotica. His grandfather was a winery bookkeeper, but also owned more than twenty thousand vines growing in sand. They included Graševina, Kövidinka, Kadarka, Chasselas and Slankamenka, varieties that later disappeared from vineyards much faster than from Ernő’s memory.

Two smells stayed with him from those days.

The first belonged to his grandfather’s small barrel of Muscat Ottonel. Ernest neither drank it every day nor offered it to everyone. He kept it, as he said, “for the ladies”. Occasionally, he would hold a glass beneath his grandson’s nose and let him smell the wine, but never taste it. That floral, powdery fragrance became Ernő’s first experience of wine, long before he knew anything about varieties, vineyard sites or fermentation.

The second smell was less noble but proved equally enduring. Once, they were returning from the vineyard in a horse-drawn cart, and the horse spent almost the entire journey-a full hour-defecating.

“I couldn’t escape it for days. It smelled like the end of the world.”

Between Muscat “for the ladies” and a horse that turned the journey into a moving stable lay his first wine education. A vineyard meant digging, pruning, dust, heavy buckets and work that had to be done when its time came. Wine was part of everyday life, but did not yet look like a calling.

Ernő enrolled in civil engineering in Subotica and maintained an average grade of 9.5 out of ten. Everything pointed towards an orderly engineering career until illness knocked him out of his own life. Amoebic dysentery went undiagnosed for too long, leaving him virtually tethered to the toilet for almost two years, exhausted and uncertain whether he would ever return to normal life.

“I didn’t know whether I would survive.”

He never returned to his studies. After recovering, he began working as a teaching assistant at a specialist mathematics secondary school, then as a mathematics teacher. Wine remained on the sidelines, although he never abandoned it entirely. In the 1990s, he owned vineyards of old Kövidinka and Ezerjó vines near Subotica, making small quantities for himself and friends. He later sold some of those vineyards to Oszkár Maurer and others to fellow winemakers, but those wines brought back into his life a man he had grown up with in Kanjiža.

József Nagy had left their hometown and built an international career as a dancer and choreographer. In France, he became artistic director of the choreographic centre in Orléans, but remained connected to Ernő through friendship, art and wine. He brought him bottles from Burgundy, the Loire Valley and Bordeaux, and particularly loved Châteauneuf-du-Pape. Ernő knew how to make wine. József had tasted his Kövidinkas back in the 1990s and evidently had not forgotten them.

Ernő remembers his offer clearly:

“I want to open a winery with you. I’ll take care of the money, and we’ll split everything fifty-fifty.”

The offer came from someone who knew Ernő beyond conversations about wine. József had watched him buying wild elderberries and distilling rakija, knew how he worked and trusted his feeling for wine long before the wine-drinking public had heard of him.

“He’s like a sorcerer-he senses things! He was extraordinarily generous. I only asked for one night to think.”

That night, he admits, he did not think particularly hard. By morning, however, he knew he would accept only on one condition. The “little man” inside him warned that years would pass before the vineyard bore fruit, and by then perhaps nothing he had built would be in his name.

When they met again, he told József:

“Forgive me, everything sounds fine, but I’ll only join if at least a third of the vineyard is registered in my name.”

József did not negotiate for long.

“No! Half the land will be in your name!”

“That was impossible to refuse.”

It was 2008. Ernő had someone willing to invest, but still had neither vineyard nor winery. He had experience with his grandfather’s vines, several harvests of his own, his friend’s trust and enough stubbornness to avoid looking for the easiest land.

So they began exploring Fruška Gora.

They wanted to know where vineyards had existed before history, phylloxera and changes in agriculture thinned them out or erased them. They travelled across Fruška Gora from Ilok to Irig, examining slopes and digging into the soil.

Eventually, they chose three sites around Irig: Kanias above Neradin, Devas and Kew, also known as Kamen-Stone. Across approximately seven hectares, they acquired three different viticultural worlds. Limestone dominates Kanias, at around 280 metres above sea level; Devas is more gravelly, while at Kew, around 320 metres up, a thin layer of soil covers rock, predominantly magnesium-rich serpentinite.

The Hungarian word kő means stone. The site later gave its name to the wine that would become almost synonymous with the winery: Furmint Kew.

When Ernő and József first visited Kamen, they did not behave like serious investors assessing a plot’s profitability. They knelt, picked up pieces of rock, laughed and began biting them.

“We ate stones like children. That was when we knew we’d found what we were looking for.”

The rock they tried to eat would later sustain vines yielding no more than eight hundred grams each, even in the most productive years. The vineyard is so steep that grapes are harvested by hand in several passes, taking only fully ripe bunches.

József loved Burgundy, so they planted some Pinot Noir. Ernő, however, wanted to restore varieties that had once defined Fruška Gora. He chose Kadarka and Furmint, with smaller quantities of Sremska Zelenika and Hárslevelű. He wanted to discover whether these almost forgotten grapes could once again produce great wines where they had formerly grown, rather than reconstruct the past as a piece of folklore.

Furmint first had to be restored to Serbia’s official list of grape varieties. The process was lengthy, but such things regularly happen to Ernő: he chooses a grape or site requiring more patience than a sensible business plan would recommend, then behaves as though no alternative ever existed.

“Furmint used to be widespread on Fruška Gora, but it was almost entirely grubbed up during the twentieth century. I found claims in Hungarian sources that it originated here, although Tokaj and Sopron naturally have their own stories. Clearly, it has been present throughout this whole area for a very long time, but Fruška Gora was a centre of winegrowing activity in the Middle Ages.”

For Kadarka, he found records suggesting it had occupied more than half of Fruška Gora’s vineyards before phylloxera. It disappeared almost everywhere, and Ernő considered it neither exclusively Serbian nor Hungarian.

“The fairest thing is to say it belongs to this whole region: Serbia, Hungary, Bulgaria and Romania. When it ripens, its seed never turns completely brown. Part of it always stays green, as though saying: ‘I’ll never grow entirely old. Something of childhood will always remain in me.’”

He associated that childlike quality with the elegance and liveliness of its wines. Kadarka did not offer the power and ripe tannins through which great reds often asserted themselves. Everything lay in nuances, demanding more attention from the winemaker.

“When it ripens beautifully, Kadarka may be the best wine in the world.”

He had nowhere to make his first wines. Meanwhile, he had met Oszkár Maurer, who offered space at his winery. The two explored similar questions, read Hungarian and English books, spoke to colleagues in Hungary and Italy, and learned together from what happened in the cellar.

“I can’t say I learned from Oszkár. It would be more accurate to say we learned from each other.”

That was how Ernő’s first wines from 2010 and 2011 came into being. He farmed without herbicides or synthetic treatments from the outset, but never regarded “organic winemaker” as a title. He wanted customers to choose the contents of the bottle, rather than a certificate.

“My wines are organic because that’s how I work, and the only way I can work. But being singled out as an organic winemaker isn’t my goal. I want to make great wines of Fruška Gora.”

He did not particularly miss certification. When asked to pay around sixteen hundred euros annually for two hectares of vineyard, his calculation was brief.

“I’m not giving them that money!”

Nor was he enthusiastic about biodynamics applied as a set of blindly copied instructions. Horns, preparations and phases of the moon meant little if the grower did not understand why they were being used.

“It’s the same as art. If there’s only logic and no emotional depth, it’s no longer art but business. Wine is the same.”

He protected the vines with a preparation based on orange essential oil, leaving the vineyards smelling of citrus after treatment. He also used sulphur, kaolin, seaweed and other products permitted in organic farming, but made no spectacle of his methods. In the cellar, preserving what the grapes had experienced in the vineyard mattered more than meeting a predetermined technical formula.

That was why he planted the same varieties on all three sites. Furmint from Kanias, Devas and Kew became three different wines, as did Kadarka. The same clone, the same vintage and only a few kilometres between them produced wines that could not be mistaken for one another.

He also understood them through an energy map of his own. Kanias was Venus, Devas Jupiter and Kew Mars. The Grgeteg convent lies near Kanias, so he associated that vineyard with a feminine principle, roundness and softness. Devas he saw as a stronger, masculine site, while Kamen represented a struggle with ground that gave the vine nothing for free.

“They’re completely different places energetically, and you can feel it. We can all sense such things, but we hardly use that kind of understanding any more. Humanity is moving towards feeling nothing, so that more and more other things can be sold to us.”

He bottled his first wine in a token quantity in 2011. It was a Kadarka called Sziget, meaning “island” in Hungarian. The name drew on the old Hungarian perception of Fruška Gora as an island between the Danube and Sava. The wine reached Budapest’s Tanti restaurant, which later received a Michelin star, and sold out in three weeks.

Ernő nevertheless once submitted his Kadarka to a competition in Hungary. It finished around twentieth.

“I regretted it. My wine was already on a Michelin-starred restaurant’s list, and at the competition it came twentieth. But even that doesn’t matter. What does it mean to me whether a wine receives 88, 92 or 95 points? The most important part of wine is emotion, and that’s absent from those scores. Wine isn’t sport.”

It was an appropriate outcome for a man who had taught mathematics but did not believe wine could be reduced to numbers.

Mathematics, admittedly, did not allow him to become careless in the winery. Ernő knows precisely how much sulphur he has added, the fermentation temperature, how long the wine spent on its lees and the yield of each vine. He objects to applying knowledge and rules without understanding them.

“Rules are guidelines. A winemaker has to understand their essence, then adapt them to his own conditions, because every year is different. You can’t always do the same thing in the same way.”

Wines required to remain almost identical from year to year trouble him most. He knows producers who send samples to laboratories to make a new vintage resemble its predecessor as closely as possible. He understands the commercial logic, but surprise is precisely what he refuses to remove from wine.

“Making wine solely from laboratory instructions is like learning how to kiss from a book. All right, perhaps you follow the book the first time, but afterwards you have to find yourself and your own emotion. If you’re closed to experience and to yourself, you’d better not make wine!”

He refuses to set even his own style in concrete. It took years to find his direction, and by the middle of the last decade he finally stopped fearing every change. Until then, he worried about making mistakes, producing poor wine or ending up with something he would not enjoy. Once he understood what he wanted, the panic disappeared, though he remained willing to change an idea if it proved wrong.

“The most important thing is for a winemaker to have a vision and follow it.”

“And if the vision fails?”

“Then you change it.”

“The vision or the profession?”

“The vision. You don’t have to change professions straight away.”

He did not, however, test changes on a single barrel while protecting the rest of production from risk. Once he believed in a new direction, he committed the entire vintage to it.

“I don’t like playing small. Then I don’t feel the weight of the risk.”

That approach led him towards very low-sulphur wines in 2011. Not all the first attempts succeeded, but once he identified his mistakes, one decision followed another. He harvested by hand in several passes, entrusted fermentation to native yeasts, kept the wines on their lees and bottled without filtration. He wanted to preserve what the grapes brought from the vineyard.

“I don’t like the expression ‘natural wine’. Many people use it because it’s fashionable, and if something else became fashionable tomorrow, they’d make that instead. Then it’s marketing rather than a genuine commitment.”

He did not regard sulphur as an enemy. He added little, sometimes only around thirty milligrams per litre before bottling, but refused to compete over who could produce the lowest laboratory reading.

“Sulphur occurs naturally in food, and in wine after fermentation too. Having it in wine isn’t a catastrophe. What matters to me is keeping it as low as possible and preserving what the grapes themselves carry.”

His philosophy constantly weighs freedom against control. He neither stripped the grapes of their own yeasts nor forced the wine to repeat the previous vintage, but he did not leave it unattended either.

“I don’t want to force an outcome. I want to let the wine be what it is.”

In his cellar, Furmint may offer the clearest example. The grape has no forcefully distinctive aroma that might obscure the site. Ernő says it has a fullness close to Chardonnay and acidity reminiscent of Riesling, without needing to impose its own aromatic signature.

“Furmint doesn’t insist on its own way. It passes into the wine what it takes from the soil. That’s why it shows differences between sites so well.”

At Kamen, vines grow above serpentinite rock on a steep slope where machines cannot replace people. The grapes are gently whole-bunch pressed, and spontaneous fermentation takes place in five-hundred-litre Serbian oak barrels. The wine then ages on its lees, settles in stainless steel and only afterwards goes into bottle.

A vintage of Furmint Kew generally yields between one and three thousand bottles; in 2016, only 450 were filled. The 2016, 2019 and 2020 vintages were each named Serbia’s best white wine in selections by Vino.rs. By the end of 2025, enough years had accumulated for a Belgrade tasting of nine different editions, spanning 2015 to 2023 and including a traditional-method sparkling wine.

Of certain vintages, Ernő could bring only one bottle. Sometimes these were his very last bottles.

The 2023 vintage developed differently, with elevated volatile acidity, and was therefore not released as Kew. Ernő called it Elit A Lov, a name that reads “volatile” backwards. Instead of concealing the difference and forcing the wine under a familiar label, he turned it into a new name.

It was a typically Ernő response to a year that had failed to read his production plan.

Kadarka presented another challenge. He sought subtlety rather than power: lovely acidity, gentle tannins, strawberry, raspberry and layers that revealed themselves gradually. In 2016, he followed advice from Italian winemaker Roberto Voerzio, but did not copy him as though following a recipe. If pressed to name an inspiration, he most often looked to Burgundy.

“To me, those are serious wines.”

Asked whether, if forced, he would give up Furmint or Kadarka, he was left without a ready answer for the first time.

“Don’t ask me that. If I answer, I won’t be allowed back into the cellar.”

That cellar produces approximately fifteen thousand bottles annually. Little enough for a large industrial winery to bottle before lunch, yet enough for Ernő to sell almost every one. Buyers emerged in Belgrade, Budapest, Berlin and the United States, while LH Zero became a label he says he could sell in far greater quantities than he can produce.

Meanwhile, the winery changed its name. Initially Nagy–Sagmeister, it became Dukay–Sagmeister after József left the partnership. József had fallen in love, wanted to buy a flat in Budapest and sold his share. There was no quarrel or dramatic parting. Ernő’s childhood friend, the doctor Krisztián Dukay, took his place.

“It seems I must never be left alone in the most important things. Someone always appears who believes in me more than I believe in myself.”

First József, then Krisztián, then the drinkers who embraced his wines before he fully believed he had found his own path.

They initially discovered him through the people who sold the wines, put them on restaurant lists and presented them at festivals. He felt particularly strong support in Belgrade, where his wines acquired an almost cult following among younger drinkers over several years. Sales grew, but Ernő did not try to produce more than his vineyards and working methods allowed.

“If you work from the heart, you can’t make three hundred thousand bottles a year. That’s industry rather than wine.”

He spoke as a winemaker who knew how much attention he could give each barrel, rather than a man who despised large wineries. He did not want to become the manager of an operation that would distance him from the vineyards for which he drove three hundred kilometres a day.

Nor did he see the market as an enemy. He respected his audience and readily acknowledged the merchants, restaurateurs and wine-event organisers who helped him reach it. He refused only to make wines he would not enjoy himself simply to offer customers the same flavour every year.

“Drinkers in Serbia are quite emotional, and I like that. People try to experience wine through their own lives, rather than only through the way wine judges assess it.”

“I find it terribly arrogant when someone calls themselves a Master of Wine but has never made wine! They may be an expert in tasting, describing wine or something else, but you don’t get to know wine only through a glass.”

Recognition did not change his attitude towards competitions. The winery was named Serbia’s best small winery in 2021, three Furmint Kew vintages were named best white wine, and his Kadarkas and Furmints reached prestigious wine lists. He accepted the recognition without beginning to make wines for judging panels.

He preferred tasting with people whose opinions he knew. For years, he exchanged the most experience with Oszkár Maurer, alongside whom he explored organic viticulture and minimal-intervention winemaking in his early days. Their paths gradually diverged, but Ernő spoke freely about which of Oszkár’s wines he liked most.

“Kadarka. I’m slightly less fond of his skin-macerated whites, although I’ve also drunk some very good Blaufränkisch. I definitely prefer his reds.”

And did he drink wines that were not organic?

“If I have to.”

It sounded like a joke, but he immediately distanced himself from the wine sect he had no wish to join.

“I don’t think people who drink only organic wine are better than anyone else. Organic or non-organic is only one part of the picture. Many other things define a wine and the person who makes it.”

In his Kanjiža home, that wider picture consisted of more than wine. His wife Laura is a painter, and her large oils filled the walls, interspersed with photographs of jazz musicians from the town’s former festival. Art was part of the life from which the wines emerged, rather than decoration added afterwards to give the winery personality.

In the vineyards, he wanted each site to speak differently even when planted with the same grape. Kanias, Devas and Kew were evidence that wine could convey differences a person could see, touch or merely sense beneath their feet, rather than three labels created to broaden the range.

“Openness and dedication. That’s my entire wine philosophy.”

And if the whole venture failed?

Ernő could always return to mathematics. In theory, at least: he had studied civil engineering with an average grade of 9.5, taught school and already built one life independent of grapes. Yet a man who drives from Kanjiža to Irig every day for a few hectares of vineyard stopped making decisions according to calculations a mathematics teacher might consider sensible long ago.

Almost every morning, he therefore sets off for the vineyards again. He knows his destination but deliberately changes the route: through Senta one day, Horgoš another, then through villages nobody sensible would choose if trying to save time.

Ernő Sagmeister has never chosen the road that saves time.

In the cellar, he does not want to repeat the previous vintage. On the road, he does not want to repeat yesterday’s bend.

“If you keep taking the same road, your thinking dies.”

That is why the destination is the same every day, but the journey never is.